Christmas 1949 at 817 Seventh Avenue, Grinnell, Iowa. From left to right: Charles Austin Palmer, Nora Belle Palmer, Dorothy Tarleton Palmer, Cynthia Palmer, Gladys Schoonover Palmer, Benjamin P. Tarleton.
Four generations appear in this family picture. From left to right: Dorothy Tarleton Palmer, Elizabeth Schoonover holding baby Cynthia Palmer, and Gladys Schoonover Tarleton. Elizabeth is Gladys' mother; Gladys is Dorothy's mother; and Dorothy is Cynthia's mother.